Kiera Cass: The Selection - The Selection Book 1

The Selection by Kiera Cass is essentially dystopian style The Bachelor. What if the prince of a country had to choose his wife on live TV from a pool of eligible girls? America Singer is one of those girls. She is fairly low on the caste totem pole (a 6 to the royal 1) and is in love with a boy in her neighborhood. She entered the contest to appease his concerns that he was holding her back. She enters, tries to spoil him, and he breaks up with her. America is then chosen for the Selection and meets Prince Maxon who is nothing like she expected. Will America make it to the end of the Selection?

Ultimately, this book was not the most enjoyable book I've ever read. It wasn't terrible, but I found it predictable, and I wasn't impressed with the ending. I liked the overall idea, even if it wasn't all that original, and I personally have no interest in reality shows like The Bachelor. I thought America's name was unoriginal, and I found her character a little obnoxious. It was also written from the first person which made it rather obvious that America wasn't going to wash out. If you really want to write a contest story where the reader can't guess what's going to happen, don't write in the first person! It was pretty obvious to me that America was going to resist liking Maxon and still hold out her hope for the other boyfriend, and that said boyfriend would show back up, which he did.

As I stated before, the ending was inconvenient. I feel like there are two kinds of conflict when looking at series: series level conflicts (conflicts that span an entire series) and book-level conflicts (issues that should be resolved within one book). The Selection doesn't seem to tie up any of the conflicts. The contest isn't over at the conclusion, there is still a rebellion, and America still likes both boys. I felt that at least the contest should have finished in the first book, not a narrowing down to the top few.

Overall, in talking about this book with my students (ironically several of my students read this just after I did), most of them liked it. The romance and the main character do seem to resonate with teenage readers. They didn't even really notice the predictability of the plot. My rating did not match theirs at all.

My rating:

PG
3 Stars

Comments

Brandon Sanderson: The Alloy of Law - Wax and Wayne (Mistborn era 2) book 1

Again, I had this book finished quite some time ago (shortly after finishing The Hero of Ages ) and I just haven't had a lot of time to get to posting my review. I am now about halfway through the next book, and now that the term is over, I'm hoping I will have a little more time to finish that book. The Alloy of Law by Brandon Sanderson introduces Era 2 in the world of Mistborn . No longer does the world of the Final Empire exist, but it has literally been remade by Harmony, or the character of Sazed and the Hero of Ages that readers might recognize from The Hero of Ages . In this world, Waxillium Ladrian is a lawman in the Roughs. At least he was, until his uncle and sister unexpectedly died, and Wax is forced to assume control of the noble house he is now heir to. He finds the city is no less in need of a lawman than the Roughs, and is soon embroiled in the investigation into The Vanishers. Once his fiancee is kidnapped, and his butler tries to blow him up, Wax is fully in

Ruta Sepetys: I Must Betray You

I read this novel for Battle of the Books, but I also wanted to read it. I keep trying Sepetys novels, thinking I'm really going to like them, and then finding myself disappointed. This novel was an exception. This is probably the best Sepetys novel I've read so far. I Must Betray You is the story of Romania behind the Iron Curtain. Christian Florescu is seventeen. His grandfather, an intellectual, questions the current regime, and Christian finds himself agreeing. Romanians are struggling; waiting in long lines hoping for food, spies everywhere, never knowing who's an informer and who isn't. Amidst these tensions, Christian is confronted by an agent of the secret police and blackmailed into informing on Dan Van Dorn, the son of the American Ambassador. Stuck between his beliefs and his fear, Christian does as he's told, hoping that he can dupe the agent. I loved this book, more than any other Sepetys novel I've read. While Sepetys excels at many things in her w

Brandon Sanderson: The Emperor's Soul

As Elantris is probably my favorite Sanderson book of all time, I was excited to see this novella that takes place in the same world. I listened to this on Audible, and it went really quickly (I think it's about 3 hours total). The Emperor's Soul follows the story of Shei, a Forger, who has been arrested for Forging a copy of a painting in the Emperor's palace. Unbeknownst to Shei, the Emperor was injured in an assassination attempt, and his mind was broken. Knowing her great skill, the bureaucrats in charge of the Empire offer her a trade: her life, for a forgery of the Emperor's soul. This feat is nearly impossible, and Shei knows this, but she accepts the chance at freedom. Will Shei actually be able to recreate the Emperor? This novella was beautifully written. I loved Shei's personality, and the conflicts she had with the Empire. I found it fascinating to learn more about her, and her attempts to thwart being manipulated. I thought her story was fascinating i

Books I Read and Other Assorted Oddities

Search This Blog