Erik Larson: The Devil in the White City

This is a book I've used as an option in my AP class. It was the only book I hadn't read for the longest time. I finally finished it, and here is my review.

The Devil in the White City covers two true stories. The first is the story of the World's Fair in Chicago in 1893. This part of the book follows the story of how the fair was built and the work that went into it by the famous architect Daniel H. Burnham. The second storyline follows the life of America's first serial killer, Dr. H. H. Holmes, who was active at the time of the World's Fair. Both accounts are true and pulled from primary source documents. Larson attempts to use the voices of the actual people involved wherever possible.

This book was an interesting account on both sides. The individual stories were interesting, detailed, and as I said, Larson pulled from primary sources wherever possible. He often uses the "characters'" words when recounting their story. I enjoyed this aspect of it and found both stories compelling.

The major issue with this book comes with how it's constructed. I really think Larson tried to do too much with this book. The two storylines attempt to juxtapose the "white city" (moniker for the world's fair) and Holmes's evil actions, but they're not all that related. I think if they had been two separate books, they would have been better. Mashed into one story made it feel disjointed. This is the complaint my students have with it as well: he tried to do too much and tried to connect two stories that have only vague connections. Maybe if he had put all of the world's fair into one part and all of the Holmes story into the second part, it would have been more successful?

I rate this book PG or PG-13 for the grisly descriptions of Holmes's murders. I gave this book ⭐⭐⭐

Comments

Some Forgotten Thoughts--Eragon vs. The Belgariad

I forgot to mention something I noticed about Eragon in my last post. If any of you have read David Edding's Belgariad series, then you might have realized that many ideas about the workings of magic in Eragon follow along with the Belgariad . For example, the "Be Not" principle is a very important one in book three of the Belgariad and has some of the same effects that it does in Inheritance (book four of the cycle). "Magic" in Eragon can be equated to "sorcery" in The Belgariad . Magic in both series depends upon your personal strength. You can't bring people back from the dead (this is a common rule throughout all of the magical fantasy). Another similarity is that there are different kinds of magic. Shades are spirits trapped in the mortal world in Eragon . Eddings actually portrays basically the same idea as an actual demon. Mispronunciation or breaking of concentration will cause the Shade or demon to destroy the ma...

Dashka Slater: The 57 Bus

I picked this one up to possibly use in my AP class. It had been recommended to me by one of my coworkers and I was trying to decide if it was worth using in AP. The 57 Bus recounts the true story of two teens whose happenstance meeting on a public bus in Oakland, California. Sasha identified as nonbinary, liked to wear skirts, and went to a private school in Oakland. Richard was a black student, a good kid, but also tended to get mixed up in trouble. He went to a public school in Oakland's poorer side of town. One day, Sasha was riding the bus as they always did back to their house from school. This time though, Sasha fell asleep on the long ride. Richard and his friends boarded the bus as well, and seeing the skirt hanging off the edge of the seat, decided to see what would happen with a lighter. The material of the skirt burst into flames, and suddenly Sasha was burning. This story is unbelievably sad for both teenagers involved. In working with teenagers, one thing is tr...

Robert Louis Stevenson: Pavilion on the Links

For anyone who has read Stevenson's short story "Pavilion on the Links" here is a short discussion of the story and a key passage. For anyone who hasn't, here is a short explication dealing with a passage from the short story. The prompt is as follows: In "The Pavilion on the Links," Frank Cassilis, the story's narrator, describes his friend Northmour: "My wife and I, a man and a woman, have often agreed to wonder how a person could be, at the same time, so handsome and so repulsive as Northmour. He had the appearance of a finished gentleman; his face bore every mark of intelligence and courage; but you had only to look at him, even in his most amiable moment, to see that he had the temper of a slaver captain. I never knew a character that was both explosive and revengeful to the same degree; he combined the vivacity of the south with the sustained and deadly hatreds of the north; and both traits were plainly written on his face, which was...

Books I Read and Other Assorted Oddities

Search This Blog